Scapegoat Ethics: The Logic of the Necessary Victim

While the term 'scapegoat' has biblical origins, its ethical application in modern philosophy often centers on the 'intentionality' of the victimhood. Unlike a tragic accident, Scapegoat Ethics involves a conscious social choice. The community identifies a 'vessel' for its suffering or its sins, and by isolating that vessel, the rest of the community is cleansed or enriched. In the context of the Omelas dilemma, the child is the literal scapegoat upon whom the city's light is founded.

René Girard, a key theorist in this field, argued that the scapegoat mechanism is the foundation of human culture. He posited that societies are prone to 'mimetic desire'—everyone wanting what others have—which leads to conflict. The only way to stop the 'war of all against all' is to find a common enemy or victim. By killing or ostracizing the scapegoat, the community finds a temporary, bloody peace. Omelas is the sanitized, bloodless version of this Girardian ritual, where the violence is hidden behind a locked door but remains the engine of order.

Scapegoat ethics is the dark underbelly of 'pragmatism.' It is what happens when we decide that some people are simply 'more expendable' than others for the sake of the project.

In modern political theory, Scapegoat Ethics is often discussed in relation to 'State of Exception' (Giorgio Agamben) or 'Necropolitics' (Achille Mbembe). It describes how modern states decide who 'matters' and who can be 'sacrificed' for the sake of national security or economic growth. Whether it is the 'disposable worker' in a pandemic or the 'collateral damage' in a drone strike, the logic remains the same: the health of the many requires the hurt of the few.

The ethical challenge to scapegoating is found in the 'person-affecting principle,' which argues that an act is only good if it is good for someone, and no amount of 'good for others' can cancel out the 'bad for the victim.' To move beyond scapegoat ethics requires a commitment to universal rights that cannot be suspended, even in the name of utopia.

If you found this valuable, consider supporting our work.